Do You Need a Police Report for an Insurance Claim in Ontario?

Introduction

After a car accident, many drivers and passengers ask:
“Do I really need a police report for my insurance claim?”

Some people assume that if their injuries seem minor or the vehicle damage looks small, they can skip police involvement. Others fear delays, penalties, or legal consequences. Unfortunately, failing to file a required police report can seriously damage your insurance claim and your legal rights.

In Ontario, you do not always need a police report — but in many situations, you are legally required to file one. This guide explains:

• When a police report is mandatory
• When it may not be required
• What happens if you fail to report
• How police reports affect fault, insurance, and lawsuits

✅ When Is a Police Report Legally Required in Ontario?

Under Ontario law, you must report an accident to police if any of the following apply:

✅ Someone is injured
✅ Total property damage exceeds $2,000
✅ A driver is suspected of:

• Impaired driving
• Criminal behavior
• Driving without insurance
  ✅ The accident involves:
• A pedestrian
• A cyclist
  ✅ The driver fled the scene (hit and run)

Failing to report in these situations can result in:

• Fines
• License suspension
• Criminal charges
• Insurance claim denial

✅ Police vs. Collision Reporting Centres (CRC)

Not all accidents require an officer at the scene. Ontario uses Collision Reporting Centres (CRC) for many non-emergency cases.

✅ Go to a CRC If:

• No one is injured
• Damage appears under $2,000
• Vehicles are drivable
• No criminal activity suspected

At a CRC, you will:

• File a formal police accident report
• Take vehicle photos
• Provide driver information
• Receive an official report number

Your insurer often requires this CRC report number.

✅ Do You Always Need a Police Report for an Insurance Claim?

✅ For property damage only (minor) — Not always
✅ For injury claims — Almost always
✅ For hit and run — Always
✅ For MVACF claims — Always
✅ For lawsuits — Strongly recommended

Technically, your insurer may open a claim without a police report. However, in practice:

⚠️ Lack of a police report often leads to:

• Claim delays
• Fault disputes
• Reduced settlement offers
• Accusations of fraud
• Denial of accident benefits

✅ Why Police Reports Are So Important for Injury Claims

Police reports provide:

• Independent accident documentation
• Official time & location verification
• Driver identification
• Witness information
• Initial fault observations
• Evidence of injury at the scene

Insurance companies rely heavily on police reports to:

• Confirm accidents occurred
• Assign liability
• Detect staged or fraudulent claims

✅ What Happens If You Don’t Have a Police Report?

Without a report:

• Your version of events may be challenged
• The other driver may deny fault
• Witness evidence may disappear
• Insurance companies may argue:
  • The accident was minor
  • Injuries occurred later
  • The crash did not happen as claimed

This is especially dangerous for:

• Whiplash
• Concussions
• Soft tissue injuries
• Psychological trauma

✅ Special Situations

✅ 1. Hit and Run Accidents

A police report is:
✅ Absolutely mandatory

Without it:

• MVACF will refuse your claim
• Insurers may deny accident benefits
• Criminal investigation cannot proceed

✅ 2. Pedestrian & Cyclist Accidents

Always report. These cases carry:

• Higher injury severity
• Greater liability exposure
• Commercial vehicle involvement

✅ 3. Accidents on Private Property

Parking lots, plazas, driveways:
✅ Still report if injuries occurred or damage exceeds $2,000.

✅ 4. Delayed Injury Symptoms

If pain develops hours or days later, report immediately and update your insurer with medical proof.

✅ How to File a Police Report After an Accident

You can:

1. Call police to the scene (if required)
2. Visit a Collision Reporting Centre (within 24 hours if possible)
3. File online for some non-injury incidents
4. Update the report if new injuries appear

✅ Bring:

• Driver’s license
• Insurance policy
• Vehicle ownership
• Photos of the scene

✅ How Police Reports Affect Fault Determination

Police reports:

• Do not always legally decide fault
• But strongly influence:
  • Insurance fault rules
  • Settlement negotiations
  • Court credibility

Contradictory reports can weaken your case significantly.

✅ How Police Reports Affect Lawsuits

In court, police reports help establish:

• Timeline
• Impact severity
• Witness corroboration
• Scene credibility

Missing police documentation makes injury cases far harder to prove.

✅ Common Myths About Police Reports

❌ “If damage is small, I don’t need one.”
❌ “If both drivers agree, no report is needed.”
❌ “I can file it weeks later without issue.”
❌ “Police reports guarantee fault.”

✅ All of these are dangerous misconceptions.

✅ When to Contact a Lawyer About a Police Report Issue

You should contact a lawyer immediately if:

✅ You failed to report within required time
✅ The police report contains errors
✅ Fault is wrongly assigned
✅ The other driver disappeared
✅ Insurance is delaying your claim due to missing documentation

✅ Final Thoughts

A police report is one of the most powerful pieces of evidence in an Ontario insurance claim. Skipping it can:

• Delay your medical treatment
• Reduce compensation
• Destroy lawsuit leverage
• Lead to claim denial

When in doubt:

✅ Always report. Always document. Always protect yourself.

✅ Free Police Report & Insurance Claim Review • No Win No Fee